Queenbee-1 in the cage
Warner Britton in Apple-One remembers - "they saw the flares dropped by the C-130 ignite and was impressed by the surrealistic appearance of the illuminated landscape. This light enabled commander to see Donohue, Apple-Three, hovering across the building complex toward which they were heading. They noticed that he didn't fire as scheduled and commented on this to Montrem. Then Kalen followed the first aircraft and he did fire. That was the last Montrem and they saw, as just after Kalen crossed the buildings, they’re landing on a heading slightly away from the buildings, so that their troops could proceed out the rear ramp and have their objective in sight. They had no idea that they had landed in the wrong place until they had taken off and turned toward the holding area. Memory’s Commander of what happened next differs slightly from that of some others. He believed that they took off, flew to their holding pattern-area about few minutes away and landed. They returned immediately when Donohue, in Apple-Three, told us they had landed in the wrong place. They were also in contact with Col Simon's group. Others, including Montrem, believe that they returned to pick them up without landing at the holding area. In any case, very little time passes before they’re back on the ground at the so-called "training-school" In the meantime, Jack Allison in Apple-Two carrying Bud Sydnor and his force, had landed at the correct predetermined spot and realizing that Apple-One was not with him immediately put an alternate plan in effect. Within a few minutes, however, he returned to the primary plan when the erring force was in place.
Jay Strayer from Apple-Two observed – “As they neared their objectives, they sensed that they were not going the right way to the Son Tay Camp, and mentioned it more than once to Jack. Quite suddenly they were sure of it; they’re about to land at the Military Camp to the south of Son Tay! The amazing thing to the commander at the time, and remains so, is that no one had the forethought to break radio silence and say so! Indeed, Apple-Three had almost taken the camp under fire, discovered his error in time, and turned north to the correct place.” Jack Allison, in the holding area, recalls – Sitting in the holding area waiting to be recalled to pick up the POWs and ground forces, Apple flight was treated to a spectacular fireworks display. 14 to 16 SAMs were fired at the F-105 “Wild Weasel” aircraft, although one was at such a low angle, one of the departing helicopters took evasive action. One SAM was observed to explode and spray fuel over Firebird-Three. The aircraft descended in a ball of fire and appeared to be a loss. However the fire blew out and the crew continued with the mission. Another SAM exploded near Firebird-Five, inflicting damage to his flight controls and fuel system. The crews later bailed out over the Plaine-des-Jarres highland at Laos and were picked up at first light by Apple-Four and -Five." While all the helicopters were engaged with he compound and A-1s Skyraider, which had arrived with the second C-130, were doing their thing. Bob Senko in Peach Two recollects - Ed Gochenaur and they’re in Peach-Two. They’re on Major Rhein' Wing. They had an automatic radio frequency change when they entered the target area. Only one aircraft forgot, and that was him. But they’re able to keep up with what was going on visually. Both Goch and him knew right away that none of the helicopters hand gone to the wrong area, but were pretty helpless to do much other than support the troops as best they could. Everything got better organized for them when he got the frequency right. It got better for the troops when they got to the right area.
Because they were out of position, they got called to pay close attention to the road from the south, to make sure no-one took advantage of our situation. When they got the order to shut down the foot bridge between the Citadel and Son Tay, lead and Goch got lined up headed east to take the bridge out with a couple of 100# Willie-Pete bombs. The commander hollered at Goch that he was too shallow, but he let the WPs go anyway and they were pretty short. Fortunately, his run in line was across a chemical factory (if that was what it was) and he greased it. There was a beautiful display of different color flames, with the bright green ones going-up way over the altitude they were working. Major Rhein's bombs were pretty good and the combination allowed them to get the job done. On - by the way - the reason Goch was so low on his run in was that the SAM-missiles had already started. They seemed to be pretty random at first but slowly they saw that they were at least aimed in the general direction of Son Tay Camp and were being fired on a very low trajectory. So they stayed as low as they could. They don't think any were actually targeted specifically on them. But they go our attention and they stayed pretty well in the weeds. It wasn't too hard since they had about 15-20 percent moonlight to work with and the target area was pretty well marked by the small arms going off. They’re circling the camp about 100-200 AGL and when they’re on the north side, they'd drop down to water level over the Red River. Again, because some of the ground troops were not in position to blow the bridge on the north side of the camp, they got called to take it out. Since they couldn't get enough altitude to drop any heavy stuff, they started strafing it. He don't know how productive that was, but He's pretty sure they kept any traffic off the bridge even if they didn't drop it. When the ground guys wrapped it up, they dumped their left over stuff in the Red River and headed home. One other thing he remembered vividly is that when the helicopters went in, they were to take out the guard towers with their mini-guns (7.62). They’re only to help as a last resort. When they opened fire, either they hit something explosive, or the sheer number of tracer-rounds caught the bamboo/wood towers on fire. Actually, it loomed like the exploded. It was amazing, certainly stopping any reaction from those towers."
The entire camp was searched. All North Vietnamese forces were annihilated and the devastatingly disappointing discovery was made that there were no Americans at the camp. The coded message - NEGATIVE ITEMS- was received in his command post. In disbelief he hoped that the message had become garbled in transmission. Simons and he had previously discussed this unlikely probability but know that the possibility existed. The raiding party was on the ground at Son Tay Compound for 29 minutes, within one minute of the planned time of 30 minutes. They experienced no losses. Sgt Wright suffered a broken ankle and Sgt Murry suffered a bullet wound on the inside of a thigh, a minor injury. The estimate of enemy killed was determined to be about 50. The helicopters were called in and the raiding party went aboard. After eerie-man was accounted for, they launched for the long ride back to Udorn. The SA-2 missile sites became active and were engaged by the F-105 Wild Weasels. A missile hit and severely damaged an F-105. There was a loss of fuel and an effort was made to return to the Being 707/KC-135 tankers on an orbit over the Laos space. A flame-out was experienced prior to contact with the tankers and the crew of two, Major Kilgus and Capt Lowry, ejected - landing in a mountainous area safety, uninjured. The progress of this emergency was monitored at his command post. Location of the downed airmen was relayed to the crew of HH-53s Apple-Four and -Five, Lt Col Brown and Major Kenneth Murphy, with instructions to search for and pick up the F-105 crew members. The pickup was successfully accomplished after more choppers air refueling and flare drops; all returned to Udorn safely. At Udorn he met a dejected force of raiders. They were disappointed because their hopes of returning with POWs were dashed. They had failed. This thoroughly dedicated group expressed the belief they should return the next night and search for the POWs. For many reasons, this could not be done. Did the mission result in benefits as Admiral McCain predicted? Yes, definitely. The North Vietnamese, fearing a repeat performance but not knowing when and where, closed the outlying POW camps and consolidated all POWs in the two main prisons in downtown Hanoi. These were the old French prisons of Hoa-Lo and Culac. The number of POWs at these two prisons now grew to the extent that POWs lived in groups, rather than what for many had been solitary confinement. Morale immediately improved and, as a result, general health improved. POWs have stated that lives were saved. Prison conditions to some degree generally improved. Mail delivery and food both improved substantially. Morale among next of kin, for the most part, also improved.
Jay Jayroe, former Son Tay POW, recalls -- "When the fireworks went off that clear night in November of 1970, we knew exactly what was happening - a raid on Son Tay Camp was in progress, some fifty-two of them had been moved from Hanoi to Son Tay in late 1968 and had immediately recognized it as a place for escape of rescue. During the following months they did what they could to indicate their presence there, hoping their efforts would result in success via US Airborne surveillance. However, for reasons unknown to them, in July, 1970 their captors moved them a short distance to a newly opened complex, where they were aggregated with other POWs from outlying prison camps. He did not believe the North-Vietnamese suspected an impending rescue attempt, because the move was quite frequently with no sense of urgency. The raid, as they have learned, was perfectly executed and highly successful with the exception of one minor detail - no one was rescued. But, short of being there, one cannot imagine the positive effect it had on those of them who were destined to spend some two and a half years more as POWs. One should recall that it had been two years since the US had stopped bombing North Vietnam, and their faith was being severely tried. But the Son Tay Rescue attempt dispelled all doubt: “They Were Not Forgotten; Their Country Cared!!!” During the hard times ahead, their renewed faith in God and Country served their well" -In 1973, when the 591 POWs were released, they learned that those at Son Tay had been relocated in mid-July - almost one month before the Joint Contingency Task Force was formed and trained for the rescue mission. Intelligence sources were not adequate to reveal the actual presence of POWs at specific locations on a real-time basis. Some critical intelligence had several weeks delay. The successful demonstration of their capability to execute this type of rescue mission undoubtedly had some impact on the formation, albeit 18 years later, of a Unified Command (USSOC) whose sole mission is special operations. He will always feel a great sense of admiration of the brave men who volunteered for the risky mission to rescue Americans in the heart of the enemy country. He is reminded of a scripture reading taken from the Old Testament
(continued)
Warner Britton in Apple-One remembers - "they saw the flares dropped by the C-130 ignite and was impressed by the surrealistic appearance of the illuminated landscape. This light enabled commander to see Donohue, Apple-Three, hovering across the building complex toward which they were heading. They noticed that he didn't fire as scheduled and commented on this to Montrem. Then Kalen followed the first aircraft and he did fire. That was the last Montrem and they saw, as just after Kalen crossed the buildings, they’re landing on a heading slightly away from the buildings, so that their troops could proceed out the rear ramp and have their objective in sight. They had no idea that they had landed in the wrong place until they had taken off and turned toward the holding area. Memory’s Commander of what happened next differs slightly from that of some others. He believed that they took off, flew to their holding pattern-area about few minutes away and landed. They returned immediately when Donohue, in Apple-Three, told us they had landed in the wrong place. They were also in contact with Col Simon's group. Others, including Montrem, believe that they returned to pick them up without landing at the holding area. In any case, very little time passes before they’re back on the ground at the so-called "training-school" In the meantime, Jack Allison in Apple-Two carrying Bud Sydnor and his force, had landed at the correct predetermined spot and realizing that Apple-One was not with him immediately put an alternate plan in effect. Within a few minutes, however, he returned to the primary plan when the erring force was in place.
Jay Strayer from Apple-Two observed – “As they neared their objectives, they sensed that they were not going the right way to the Son Tay Camp, and mentioned it more than once to Jack. Quite suddenly they were sure of it; they’re about to land at the Military Camp to the south of Son Tay! The amazing thing to the commander at the time, and remains so, is that no one had the forethought to break radio silence and say so! Indeed, Apple-Three had almost taken the camp under fire, discovered his error in time, and turned north to the correct place.” Jack Allison, in the holding area, recalls – Sitting in the holding area waiting to be recalled to pick up the POWs and ground forces, Apple flight was treated to a spectacular fireworks display. 14 to 16 SAMs were fired at the F-105 “Wild Weasel” aircraft, although one was at such a low angle, one of the departing helicopters took evasive action. One SAM was observed to explode and spray fuel over Firebird-Three. The aircraft descended in a ball of fire and appeared to be a loss. However the fire blew out and the crew continued with the mission. Another SAM exploded near Firebird-Five, inflicting damage to his flight controls and fuel system. The crews later bailed out over the Plaine-des-Jarres highland at Laos and were picked up at first light by Apple-Four and -Five." While all the helicopters were engaged with he compound and A-1s Skyraider, which had arrived with the second C-130, were doing their thing. Bob Senko in Peach Two recollects - Ed Gochenaur and they’re in Peach-Two. They’re on Major Rhein' Wing. They had an automatic radio frequency change when they entered the target area. Only one aircraft forgot, and that was him. But they’re able to keep up with what was going on visually. Both Goch and him knew right away that none of the helicopters hand gone to the wrong area, but were pretty helpless to do much other than support the troops as best they could. Everything got better organized for them when he got the frequency right. It got better for the troops when they got to the right area.
Because they were out of position, they got called to pay close attention to the road from the south, to make sure no-one took advantage of our situation. When they got the order to shut down the foot bridge between the Citadel and Son Tay, lead and Goch got lined up headed east to take the bridge out with a couple of 100# Willie-Pete bombs. The commander hollered at Goch that he was too shallow, but he let the WPs go anyway and they were pretty short. Fortunately, his run in line was across a chemical factory (if that was what it was) and he greased it. There was a beautiful display of different color flames, with the bright green ones going-up way over the altitude they were working. Major Rhein's bombs were pretty good and the combination allowed them to get the job done. On - by the way - the reason Goch was so low on his run in was that the SAM-missiles had already started. They seemed to be pretty random at first but slowly they saw that they were at least aimed in the general direction of Son Tay Camp and were being fired on a very low trajectory. So they stayed as low as they could. They don't think any were actually targeted specifically on them. But they go our attention and they stayed pretty well in the weeds. It wasn't too hard since they had about 15-20 percent moonlight to work with and the target area was pretty well marked by the small arms going off. They’re circling the camp about 100-200 AGL and when they’re on the north side, they'd drop down to water level over the Red River. Again, because some of the ground troops were not in position to blow the bridge on the north side of the camp, they got called to take it out. Since they couldn't get enough altitude to drop any heavy stuff, they started strafing it. He don't know how productive that was, but He's pretty sure they kept any traffic off the bridge even if they didn't drop it. When the ground guys wrapped it up, they dumped their left over stuff in the Red River and headed home. One other thing he remembered vividly is that when the helicopters went in, they were to take out the guard towers with their mini-guns (7.62). They’re only to help as a last resort. When they opened fire, either they hit something explosive, or the sheer number of tracer-rounds caught the bamboo/wood towers on fire. Actually, it loomed like the exploded. It was amazing, certainly stopping any reaction from those towers."
The entire camp was searched. All North Vietnamese forces were annihilated and the devastatingly disappointing discovery was made that there were no Americans at the camp. The coded message - NEGATIVE ITEMS- was received in his command post. In disbelief he hoped that the message had become garbled in transmission. Simons and he had previously discussed this unlikely probability but know that the possibility existed. The raiding party was on the ground at Son Tay Compound for 29 minutes, within one minute of the planned time of 30 minutes. They experienced no losses. Sgt Wright suffered a broken ankle and Sgt Murry suffered a bullet wound on the inside of a thigh, a minor injury. The estimate of enemy killed was determined to be about 50. The helicopters were called in and the raiding party went aboard. After eerie-man was accounted for, they launched for the long ride back to Udorn. The SA-2 missile sites became active and were engaged by the F-105 Wild Weasels. A missile hit and severely damaged an F-105. There was a loss of fuel and an effort was made to return to the Being 707/KC-135 tankers on an orbit over the Laos space. A flame-out was experienced prior to contact with the tankers and the crew of two, Major Kilgus and Capt Lowry, ejected - landing in a mountainous area safety, uninjured. The progress of this emergency was monitored at his command post. Location of the downed airmen was relayed to the crew of HH-53s Apple-Four and -Five, Lt Col Brown and Major Kenneth Murphy, with instructions to search for and pick up the F-105 crew members. The pickup was successfully accomplished after more choppers air refueling and flare drops; all returned to Udorn safely. At Udorn he met a dejected force of raiders. They were disappointed because their hopes of returning with POWs were dashed. They had failed. This thoroughly dedicated group expressed the belief they should return the next night and search for the POWs. For many reasons, this could not be done. Did the mission result in benefits as Admiral McCain predicted? Yes, definitely. The North Vietnamese, fearing a repeat performance but not knowing when and where, closed the outlying POW camps and consolidated all POWs in the two main prisons in downtown Hanoi. These were the old French prisons of Hoa-Lo and Culac. The number of POWs at these two prisons now grew to the extent that POWs lived in groups, rather than what for many had been solitary confinement. Morale immediately improved and, as a result, general health improved. POWs have stated that lives were saved. Prison conditions to some degree generally improved. Mail delivery and food both improved substantially. Morale among next of kin, for the most part, also improved.
Jay Jayroe, former Son Tay POW, recalls -- "When the fireworks went off that clear night in November of 1970, we knew exactly what was happening - a raid on Son Tay Camp was in progress, some fifty-two of them had been moved from Hanoi to Son Tay in late 1968 and had immediately recognized it as a place for escape of rescue. During the following months they did what they could to indicate their presence there, hoping their efforts would result in success via US Airborne surveillance. However, for reasons unknown to them, in July, 1970 their captors moved them a short distance to a newly opened complex, where they were aggregated with other POWs from outlying prison camps. He did not believe the North-Vietnamese suspected an impending rescue attempt, because the move was quite frequently with no sense of urgency. The raid, as they have learned, was perfectly executed and highly successful with the exception of one minor detail - no one was rescued. But, short of being there, one cannot imagine the positive effect it had on those of them who were destined to spend some two and a half years more as POWs. One should recall that it had been two years since the US had stopped bombing North Vietnam, and their faith was being severely tried. But the Son Tay Rescue attempt dispelled all doubt: “They Were Not Forgotten; Their Country Cared!!!” During the hard times ahead, their renewed faith in God and Country served their well" -In 1973, when the 591 POWs were released, they learned that those at Son Tay had been relocated in mid-July - almost one month before the Joint Contingency Task Force was formed and trained for the rescue mission. Intelligence sources were not adequate to reveal the actual presence of POWs at specific locations on a real-time basis. Some critical intelligence had several weeks delay. The successful demonstration of their capability to execute this type of rescue mission undoubtedly had some impact on the formation, albeit 18 years later, of a Unified Command (USSOC) whose sole mission is special operations. He will always feel a great sense of admiration of the brave men who volunteered for the risky mission to rescue Americans in the heart of the enemy country. He is reminded of a scripture reading taken from the Old Testament
(continued)

Comment